What Are The Negative Aspects Of Plastering?

Table of Contents

    While plastering is a time-honored technique for completing walls and ceilings, it is not without its flaws that can affect the quality of the work and how long it lasts. The time and effort needed to apply plaster is one of the main drawbacks of the process. Plastering is a labor-intensive process that calls for a trained artist to apply numerous coats, each of which must dry thoroughly. The construction or remodelling process will take longer and labour expenses will rise as a result of this. Making ensuring the plaster adheres properly also requires careful preparation of the underlying surface, which may be a bit of a pain if not done right.

    The fact that it could fracture and break with use is another major negative. Building settling, impact damage, or even little movements induced by changes in humidity and temperature can cause plaster to crack because it is a hard material. Repairing these fissures is necessary to avoid more damage, including water intrusion, and to restore the aesthetic value of the walls and ceilings. Fixing the damage can be a complex and expensive operation because it usually requires more than simply filling the gaps; it also has to be done while making sure the plaster layer is structurally sound.

    Additionally, plastering raises environmental problems. Plaster is made by heating gypsum to high temperatures, which is an energy-intensive process that releases carbon into the atmosphere. Additionally, plaster removal during renovations or demolitions of plastered buildings can result in a substantial amount of debris. Plaster debris can nevertheless have an effect on landfills, particularly when it comes in big amounts, even though gypsum is naturally occurring and generally harmless. The ongoing use of conventional plastering techniques is threatened by these environmental repercussions, which call attention to the necessity of eco-friendly building processes and materials. 

    Cost Considerations

    Plastering is a skilled trade that transforms our homes’ walls and ceilings, enhancing their aesthetic appeal and structural integrity. This guide delves into the nuances of plastering, drawing insights from various authoritative sources to provide a holistic view of its costs, advantages, disadvantages, and the meticulous process involved.

    Understanding Plastering Costs

    Plastering costs vary widely depending on the project’s scope, the type of plaster used, and the labour involved. For a standard 100-square-foot area, homeowners can expect to spend between $450 and $550 on average, with prices fluctuating based on the complexity of the surfaces and the finishes desired. High-end plastering projects, especially those involving intricate designs or high ceilings, can escalate to $1,200 or more, highlighting the importance of professional expertise in achieving the desired outcome.

    The Pros And Cons Of Plaster Walls

    Plastered walls offer a seamless finish that drywall cannot match, providing a robust solution that enhances fire resistance and sound insulation. However, the process has its drawbacks. The labour-intensive nature of plastering makes it a more costly option than drywall. Moreover, the skill required to achieve a flawless finish means that only some contractors can deliver the expected quality, potentially leading to dissatisfaction if the work is executed correctly.

    The Plastering Process: An Art Form

    The application of plaster is an art form that requires precision and patience. Starting with a clean, smooth surface, skilled plasterers apply a base coat to ensure adhesion, followed by subsequent, carefully smoothed and finished layers. This meticulous process can transform any space, covering imperfections and creating a canvas for further decoration.

    Regional Insights: Plastering In The Uk

    In the UK, plastering costs and techniques mirror those found globally, emphasising quality and durability. The process involves preparing the walls, applying the plaster, and then meticulously working it to achieve the perfect finish. The cost breakdown typically leans heavily towards labour, underscoring the craftsmanship involved in this traditional trade.

    Final Thoughts

    Plastering is more than just covering walls; it’s about creating a durable, aesthetically pleasing surface that stands the test of time. Whether you’re considering plaster for its practical benefits or its timeless appeal, it’s clear that this age-old technique continues to hold significant value in modern construction and renovation projects.

    what is plastering in masonry 1

    Time-Consuming Process

    Plastering, while offering a refined and durable finish to walls and ceilings, comes with challenges, particularly regarding the time and effort involved in its application and maintenance. This comprehensive analysis draws from various sources to highlight the significant time-consuming disadvantages associated with plastering.

    Extended Curing Time

    One of the primary drawbacks of traditional plastering techniques is the prolonged curing time required before the surface is ready for painting or further treatment. This process can take a month or longer in colder climates, significantly delaying construction schedules. This extended curing period is due to the moisture content in the plaster needing to evaporate entirely, a process that can be painstakingly slow.

    Labor-Intensive Application

    Plaster application, especially in traditional three-coat systems, is a labour-intensive process that demands skilled craftsmanship. Each layer, from the scratch coat to the finish coat, requires careful application and time to set correctly. This not only extends the overall project timeline but also increases labour costs.

    Complexity In Repair And Modification

    Repairing plaster walls is notably more complex and time-consuming than fixing drywall. It often involves removing a significant portion of the plaster to address cracks or damages, which can be a meticulous and lengthy process. Matching the original texture and finish during repairs adds another layer of complexity, often requiring the expertise of a skilled plasterer.

    Preparation And Installation Challenges

    The preparation of the underlying lath (in older plaster applications) or the specific mesh required for plaster adherence is time-consuming. Additionally, the actual installation of plaster, whether it’s applying multiple coats or ensuring the smoothness of the final layer, demands a high level of skill and patience, further extending project timelines.

    Moisture Sensitivity And Environmental Considerations

    Plaster’s sensitivity to moisture and requirement for a controlled environment during application and curing can pose significant delays. In areas with high humidity or unpredictable weather, ensuring the plaster dries correctly and does not absorb excess moisture can be challenging, often requiring additional time to manage these environmental factors effectively.

    Cost Implications

    While not directly related to the time aspect, the increased cost of plastering (due to its labour-intensive nature and the skill required for application) indirectly contributes to its time-consuming disadvantages. Projects may need more time as budget adjustments are made to accommodate the higher cost of plastering over alternative wall finishes.

    FAQs About Plasterer

    What Are The Main Disadvantages Of Plastering Compared To Other Wall Finishing Methods?

    Plastering is often more time-consuming, labour-intensive, and costly compared to alternatives like drywall.

    Why Is Plastering Considered Labour-Intensive?

    Plastering involves multiple steps such as preparation of surfaces, applying plaster coats, and finishing, all of which require manual labour and skill.

    What Are The Cost Implications Of Choosing Plastering For Wall Finishing?

    Plastering tends to be more expensive due to the skilled labour required and the time-intensive nature of the process.

    How Does Plastering’s Extended Curing Time Affect Construction Schedules?

    The prolonged curing time of plaster can delay subsequent construction activities like painting or further treatments, impacting project timelines.

    Is Repairing Plaster Walls More Challenging Than Repairing Other Wall Materials?

    Yes, repairing plaster walls can be complex and time-consuming, often requiring the expertise of skilled plasterers to match textures and finishes.

    Skill And Expertise Required

    Plastering, a time-honoured technique for finishing walls, demands a high level of skill and expertise, which can be seen as a disadvantage when considering the broader implications for construction and renovation projects. This analysis synthesises insights from various sources to outline the critical aspects of this disadvantage.

    Highly Skilled Labor Requirement

    Plastering is not just a construction task; it’s an art form that requires skilled artisans, unlike drywall installation, which can be learned relatively quickly and performed by many; plastering demands a level of craftsmanship that can only be achieved through extensive training and experience. This requirement for highly skilled labour can limit the availability of qualified professionals, potentially leading to delays and increased project costs.

    Increased Labor Costs

    Due to the specialised skills required for plastering, labour costs are significantly higher than other wall finishing methods like drywall. Skilled plasterers are in demand and can command higher wages, which, when combined with the meticulous and time-consuming nature of plasterwork, can substantially inflate the overall cost of a project.

    Complexity In Repair And Maintenance

    Plaster walls are known for their durability and aesthetic appeal, but when they require repair, the process is far more complex and labour-intensive than repairing drywall. Matching the texture and finish of the existing plaster can be challenging, often requiring the expertise of a skilled plasterer. This complexity increases the time needed for repairs and contributes to higher maintenance costs over the lifespan of the plastered surfaces.

    Training And Experience Gap

    As newer, more cost-effective construction methods like drywall have become prevalent, the number of professionals trained in the traditional art of plastering has yet to grow. This gap in training and experience can lead to a need for more qualified plasterers, making it difficult for homeowners and contractors to find skilled labour for plastering projects. Transferring knowledge from experienced plasterers to the next generation is crucial in preserving this craft, yet it is increasingly becoming challenging.

    Project Delays

    The need for skilled plasterers and their relative scarcity can lead to significant project delays. Plastering can only be rushed with compromising quality, and the meticulous work, from mixing to application and finishing, requires patience and precision. These factors can extend project timelines, especially when adjustments or repairs to the plaster are necessary.

    builder using plastering tool finishing old wall (1)

    Vulnerability To Cracks And Damage

    Plastering, a traditional method of finishing walls and ceilings, offers a smooth and appealing aesthetic. However, it is not without its drawbacks, particularly when it comes to its vulnerability to cracks and damage. This analysis draws insights from various expert sources to explore the reasons behind this susceptibility and its implications for property owners.

    Inherent Composition And Environmental Impact

    Plaster’s composition makes it less flexible, making it prone to cracking due to rapid environmental changes, including temperature fluctuations, humidity variations, and moisture exposure. As the plaster dries, it naturally shrinks, leading to the formation of minor fractures. This is a common phenomenon in both old constructions and new builds, where the settling of foundations or the drying and curing process can cause cracks. New constructions and extensions are particularly susceptible as they stabilise, a process that can extend up to three years, during which the weight of the building causes the plaster to move and crack.

    Structural Movement And Subsidence

    Significant cracking can indicate more severe structural issues, such as subsidence, which may result from various external factors like damaged drains, excessive rainfall, drought periods, inadequate foundations, and the root systems of nearby trees. Diagonal cracks, in particular, often stem from structural movement and can signal underlying severe problems that necessitate professional evaluation.

    Age And Quality Of Plaster

    The age of the plaster itself can also contribute to its vulnerability to cracks, especially in older homes where plaster was applied over lath and horsehair. Vibrations from renovations can cause cracks in these walls, even if the work is far from the affected area. Moreover, the quality of the plaster mix, improper mixing, or inadequate base preparation can lead to uneven drying and curing, resulting in cracks.

    Improper Application Techniques

    The technique used in applying plaster significantly affects its susceptibility to cracking. Inexperienced plasterers might apply the plaster unevenly or too thickly, leading to uneven drying and an increased likelihood of cracks forming. Rapid drying due to high temperatures, direct sunlight, or drafts can cause the outer layer of plaster to harden before the inner layers have appropriately cured, leading to cracks.

    Environmental Conditions

    Properties located on busy roads may experience slight cracking through vibrations from traffic. At the same time, replacing old window frames with uPVC double glazing can also lead to cracks around the openings. Humidity, temperature changes, and moisture levels cause the plaster and the building structure to expand and contract, leading to hairline cracks that can grow over time.

    Conclusion

    Plastering is a traditional trade that transforms walls and ceilings in homes, enhancing their aesthetic appeal and structural integrity. Plastering costs vary depending on the project scope, plaster type, and labour involved. High-end projects can cost over $1,200 or more, emphasising the importance of professional expertise. Plaster walls offer a seamless finish that drywall cannot match, enhancing fire resistance and sound insulation. However, the labour-intensive nature of plastering makes it more costly than drywall.

    The application of plaster is an art form that requires precision and patience. Skilled plasterers apply a base coat to ensure adhesion, followed by subsequent, carefully smoothed and finished layers. This meticulous process can transform any space, covering imperfections and creating a canvas for further decoration.

    Plastering is more than just covering walls; it creates a durable, aesthetically pleasing surface that stands the test of time. However, it comes with significant time-consuming disadvantages, particularly regarding the time and effort involved in its application and maintenance.

    The main drawbacks of plastering are the extended curing time, labour-intensive application, complexity in repair and modification, preparation and installation challenges, and moisture sensitivity and environmental considerations. Despite these challenges, plastering remains a valuable technique in modern construction and renovation projects.

    Plastering, a traditional finishing technique, has several disadvantages, including increased labour costs, required high skill and expertise, and more qualified professionals. This can lead to delays and increased project costs as budget adjustments are made to accommodate the higher cost of plastering over alternative wall finishes.

    Plastering is an art form that requires skilled artisans, which can limit the availability of qualified professionals, potentially leading to delays and increased costs. The complexity of repair and maintenance can also increase the time needed for repairs and contribute to higher maintenance costs over the lifespan of plastered surfaces.

    As newer, more cost-effective construction methods become prevalent, the number of professionals trained in plastering has dwindled, creating a scarcity of qualified plasterers. This can result in significant project delays, especially when adjustments or repairs are necessary.

    Plastering is also vulnerable to cracks and damage due to its inherent composition, environmental impact, structural movement, age, and quality of plaster. The age of the plaster, improper application techniques, and environmental conditions can all contribute to its vulnerability to cracking.

    In conclusion, plastering is a time-consuming and costly technique that requires skilled labour, a scarcity of qualified professionals, and environmental conditions that can lead to delays and increased costs.

    Content Summary

    • Plastering, an ancient craft cherished for its beauty and protection, has advantages and challenges.
    • Cost considerations are vital in understanding the nuances of plastering projects.
    • Plastering costs vary based on project scope, type of plaster, and labour involved.
    • Plastering costs can range from $450 to $1,200 for high-end projects.
    • Plastered walls offer superior finish and fire resistance but are costlier and require skilled contractors.
    • The plastering process demands precision and patience, transforming spaces seamlessly.
    • In the UK, plastering mirrors global techniques, prioritising quality and durability.
    • Plastering is about creating durable, visually appealing surfaces that withstand time.
    • Plastering, though refined, is time-consuming and demands considerable effort.
    • Prolonged curing times and labour-intensive applications are significant drawbacks.
    • Repairing plaster is complex, involving meticulous work to match textures.
    • Preparation and installation challenges add to the time required for plastering projects.
    • Moisture sensitivity in plastering demands controlled environments, causing delays.
    • Higher costs due to skilled labour contribute indirectly to project delays.
    • Skill and expertise are crucial in achieving desired plastering outcomes.
    • Plastering requires highly skilled artisans, limiting availability and increasing costs.
    • Increased labour costs further burden plastering projects.
    • Repairing plaster walls is complex, requiring expertise and time.
    • A gap in training and experience hampers the availability of skilled plasterers.
    • Project delays are common due to the need for more skilled labour.
    • Plaster’s vulnerability to cracks and damage poses significant challenges.
    • Plaster’s composition makes it susceptible to cracking from environmental changes.
    • Structural issues like subsidence can exacerbate plaster cracking.
    • Age and quality of plaster contribute to its vulnerability to cracks.
    • Improper application techniques increase the likelihood of plaster cracks.
    • Plastering demands meticulous attention to detail and precision.
    • Understanding the costs involved in plastering projects is crucial.
    • Skilled labour is essential for achieving desired plastering outcomes.
    • Repairing plaster requires expertise and careful matching of textures.
    • Environmental factors like moisture impact plastering timelines.
    • Plastering’s labour-intensive nature contributes to project delays.
    • The need for more skilled plasterers can prolong project timelines.
    • Cracking in plaster can signify underlying structural issues.
    • Proper application techniques are essential for crack prevention in plaster.
    • Plastering is a delicate balance between skill and precision.
    • Skilled labour is essential for the success of plastering projects.
    • Repairing plaster requires patience and expertise.
    • Environmental factors can impact the durability of plastered surfaces.
    • Time and effort are significant investments in plastering projects.
    • High-quality plastering demands skilled craftsmanship.
    • Labour costs can significantly impact the overall expense of plastering projects.
    • Matching textures during plaster repairs requires skill and attention to detail.
    • Moisture control is crucial for the success of plastering projects.
    • Structural issues must be addressed to prevent plaster cracking.
    • Age-related deterioration can affect the integrity of plastered surfaces.
    • Skilled plasterers are essential for achieving flawless plaster finishes.
    • Proper planning and preparation are vital for successful plastering projects.
    • Labour shortages can lead to delays in plastering projects.
    • Cracks in plaster can indicate underlying structural problems.
    • Expertise and precision are essential for preventing cracks in plaster.

    Eugene M has been a fixture in Melbourne's plastering scene for over 16 years, initially starting his journey as an apprentice in the bustling construction sector. His early years on job sites across Melbourne exposed him to the rich variety of plastering work, from traditional homes in the suburbs to modern commercial buildings in the city. Over time, Eugene honed his skills, learning the art of plastering, from setting drywall to mastering decorative finishes, and quickly gained a reputation for his exceptional craftsmanship and problem-solving abilities.

    Driven by a love for the craft and a desire to share his knowledge, Eugene began documenting his experiences, challenges, and insights into plastering. This eventually led to the creation of his blog, Plastering National. Here, he combines his in-depth trade expertise with a natural talent for writing, making complex plastering concepts accessible to everyone, from DIY enthusiasts to seasoned professionals. His blog covers a wide range of topics, including how-to guides, industry trends, product reviews, and maintenance tips.

    Eugene’s transition from the physical trade to becoming a full-time blogger was fueled by his belief in empowering others through knowledge. He understands the nuances of the Melbourne property market, which allows him to tailor his advice to the specific needs of the local community. Today, Eugene M continues to serve as Melbourne’s go-to plastering expert through his writing, offering valuable insights that help homeowners and professionals alike achieve flawless plastering results.

    Contact the Author

    Posted in
    Scroll to Top